I think I have to come down on the side of not liking them. One of the churches in town planted some in a small bed, and from a distance, they don't read well. The black basically disappears, and all you're left with are five narrow slashes of pale yellow, which to my eye looks a lot like five chlorotic, withered leaves. (And sometimes the actual leaves are chlorotic and/or withered, which doesn't help.)
Not saying I couldn't maybe like them in a different context -- a yellow container? against a red wall? -- but so far I'm not impressed. The only thing I'd like less in a Petunia would be solid black, and I hear they have a pronounced tendency to revert to solid black.
We planted these in quite a few containers at work. They've performed extremely well in all of them. They look especially nice when planted with pinks and purples
ReplyDeleteMmm, I do think they only look cool up close... Maybe a lot of people felt the same way because I did not end up seeing them much used in actual landscaping.
ReplyDeleteI'm fond of petunias, but have to say I don't like this color combination at all.
ReplyDeleteLove 'em. I have them hanging on my porch.
ReplyDeleteThey're OK when you can see them close up (which is what I always told my customers), but from a distance, I don't think they'd look good.
ReplyDeleteNormally I'm a Petunia hater, but we planted this guy earlier this spring. It's looking alright these days: http://www.flickr.com/photos/faroutflora/6181639950/in/photostream
ReplyDeleteIt does kind of get lost, but fulfills my need to deadhead something. Seemed to put up with barely any water all summer, too. We're giving Petunia exerta a shot, too.
Is it fragrant? Looks very weird, not sure until I see it in the flesh.
ReplyDeleteI think they would be a nice surprise in a container you walk by like near a door but I wouldn't want them in a large bed.
ReplyDeleteI grew Phantom this year. Thoughts:
ReplyDeleteNice to have a petunia with scent (Where's yours, Waves?).
Semi-compact, but pinching back really helped.
Cool weather / part-shade* is where they shine: spring and fall. The black is blackest and the yellow yellowest (I did not know that was a word ... hmm). Come summer, all that hot weather seems to drive the black from the blossoms and they get almost all yellow with a few streaks of purple. I've noticed this in other star petunias, though.
If you like petunias, this is good. It combos well with other dark foliage (the big combo seems to be Ipomoea 'Blackie', which also, for me, lost it's darkness in the full sun. Part sun* did fine.
And you can't forget it's siblings, Black Velvet, being solid, and Pinstripe, having 5 thin white lines radiating from the center.
I'll grow it again. If you like Petunias, it's a great one. If you don't, you probably won't like this one either.
Hi. I love petunias especially their colors...but they don't love me back, so I've given up on them. hehe. The black and yellow colors of the petunias in your photos is a welcoming sign for the coming Halloween! :)
ReplyDelete