If you have landed on this page because you are concerned about a child or pet who has eaten a plant, seek emergency medical help.Part 5 of a seven-part-and-two-appendix series. (Part 1) (Part 2) (Part 3) (Part 4) (Part 6) (Part 7) (Appendix 1) (Appendix 2 - Index)
In the U.S., you can call Poison Control at 1-800-222-1222 (for children), the ASPCA at 1-888-426-4435 (for pets; $60 consultation fee applies), or the Pet Poison Helpline at 1-800-213-6680 (pets; $35 fee applies).
Part 5 is about plants which are not likely to kill you, or even to result in serious injury, but which may be capable of causing vomiting, bad skin or eye irritation, diarrhea, burning, itching, or other bad things, things that you should avoid experiencing if at all possible. Like . . . I guess Paris Hilton?1 This is also the designation for a lot of the plants which are otherwise safe but bear thorns or spines that could puncture the mouth or digestive tract.
Abutilon hybridum (flowering maple) Causes skin irritation and/or allergic reactions in a few people; no info on pets but it does not appear to be particularly dangerous.
Acalypha hispida, A. reptans (chenille plant, dwarf chenille plant) The sap appears to be able to irritate the skin and digestive tract, and skin irritation is occasionally reported. Although it is in the family Euphorbiaceae, it seems not to be a particularly dangerous plant (similar to Codiaeum variegatum, q.v.).
Alpinia zerumbet (shell ginger, variegated ginger) Occasional reports of skin and eye irritation, especially in people who habitually handle large amounts of plant material (e.g. commercial propagators). Toxicity by ingestion was not known to the authors of Toxicity. Minimal risk to the average indoor (or outdoor) gardener. Likely safe for pets.
Ananas comosus (pineapple) Leaves are pointed and spiny, which poses some mechanical risk. I know for a fact that the leaves can be eaten by rabbits more or less safely. Most pineapple-related medical problems are occupational: the uncooked fruit contains an enzyme which breaks down proteins, including those in skin (fingerprint loss is not unheard of), as well as sensitizing compounds which can cause rashes and other kinds of skin irritation. More or less safe around pets and children. Very soft-skinned reptiles / amphibians may be damaged by leaf spines. Unripe fruits can be extremely unpleasant if consumed (they're pretty hardcore purgatives, among other things), but don't appear likely to kill.
Araucaria bidwillii (bunya-bunya) Nobody seems to know whether Araucaria spp. are actually toxic, but this one is sharp and pointy enough that I can't imagine anybody wanting to try it to find out.
Araucaria heterophylla (Norfolk Island pine) Not mentioned by Toxicity or Handbook. Most websites list it as safe. Should be suitable for carnivorous reptiles and amphibians, and probably herbivorous ones too. The ASPCA website claims it's toxic to cats and dogs, but I kind of don't believe the ASPCA on this one.
Bougainvillea spp. (bougainvillea) Not common indoors, because it's hard to get the right conditions for it, but it won't poison anything if you can manage to make it work. Unfortunately it's also covered in thorns and can cause injury anyway, so deal with accordingly.
Capsicum annuum (chili pepper, bell pepper, etc.) Ingestion may cause pain, burning, etc., and in large amounts or in those unaccustomed to it, nausea and vomiting may follow. This is, sadly, occasionally used by criminally sadistic parents as a means of abusing their children, favored specifically because it doesn't leave any lasting marks, which I found upsetting when I read it. (Details for those who wish to be outraged and possibly sickened in footnote 2.) Skin irritation varies wildly from individual to individual, but is worst on skin which is already damaged or naturally thin (abraded, physically burned, open wounds, mucous membranes). Repeated occupational exposure can also result in extremely painful burning sensations. The smoke from burning Capsicum annuum plants may also irritate the respiratory tract. Getting juice in the eyes is very painful, as you'd expect. None of this really appears to constitute toxicity as the word is normally understood, and one assumes that children and pets would need, at most, exactly one experience with this to understand that this is a plant best left alone, so even though it has the potential to harm, I consider it more or less a safe plant. Though it's not often grown as a houseplant anyway.
Chrysanthemum spp. (mum) The flowers may be toxic by ingestion, though neither Handbook nor Toxicity said they were. The main problem with Chrysanthemum spp. is that the flowers in particular, and to a lesser degree the leaves and stems, cause skin irritation in susceptible individuals. Which is all either book wanted to talk about. I would be wary of this one around kids and especially pets; while I doubt it kills, it does contain compounds similar to those in Hedera spp., q.v., and plus it just seems a little shifty.
Cissus quadrangularis As I noted in the profile for this plant, this is eaten on purpose by some people, though I get the impression that the amounts tend to be small. The only advice I could locate about preparing it was that one should not chew it, which suggests that it probably won't kill you, but it's probably painful or irritating to the mouth or digestive tract or whatever. Probably safe around kids and pets, though I'd hedge my bets and put it upon a high shelf somewhere anyway.
Citrus spp. (lemon, lime, orange) Rare allergic reactions have been reported, but the bigger danger is from the thorns on some varieties. The ASPCA website lists Citrus spp. as causing vomiting and diarrhea in both cats and dogs; I'm not sure if I think this is meaningful information or not, since almost everything in the world causes vomiting and diarrhea in cats and dogs.
Codiaeum variegatum (croton) Causes allergic skin irritation for some people, though repeated exposure appears to be necessary before that will start, and it doesn't appear to be especially serious when it does happen. Ingestion is supposed to cause a burning sensation, but that's as detailed as anybody gets. I'm not so much worried about this one.
Cryptanthus spp. (earth star) Bromeliads are generally safe, though some Cryptanthus spp. have sharp points on the leaf edges. So it's probably not fun to swallow, but I'm guessing you could probably eat it anyway. Though, you know, don't.
Cuphea ignea (cigar flower) Some Cuphea species irritate the skin. C. ignea is not really known to be one of them, but Toxicity felt like warning everybody anyway. Draw your own conclusions.
Dahlia spp. Dahlias are generally considered safe, though they occasionally cause skin irritation, especially for those employed in handling the tubers. I wouldn't worry much about these w/r/t kids and pets.
Dizygotheca elegantissima (more correctly Schefflera elegantissima; false aralia) I did not find any evidence that Dizygotheca elegantissima is toxic; however, given its reassignment to the genus Schefflera, one should keep in mind that it may also contain calcium oxalate crystals and skin sensitizers like Schefflera actinophylla, q.v., and S. arboricola, and might be capable of causing pain and swelling if chewed, or causing skin reactions if handled a lot.
Euphorbia pulcherrima (poinsettia) Will be covered in Appendix 1, in a couple days.
Ficus benjamina (weeping fig, "ficus tree") Ficus spp. are more or less safe for most people in most circumstances, though I have heard of people developing asthma, wheezing, and similar respiratory problems around them, and I personally get itchy when I have to pick dead leaves out of them or whatever, which suggests I might be slightly allergic. If I am slightly allergic, then I'm just being normal: allergies to Ficus, and Ficus benjamina in particular, are pretty common among greenhouse workers, florists, etc. Aside from allergies and skin or eye irritation, Ficus spp. are pretty safe.
Ficus maclellandii (long-leaf fig, alii fig, 'Alii,' 'Alli,' 'Amstel King') As for Ficus benjamina, q.v.
Ficus microcarpa / nitida / retusa (Indian laurel) As for Ficus benjamina, q.v.
Ficus pumila (creeping fig) As for Ficus benjamina, q.v.
Kalanchoe spp. including K. blossfeldiana (flaming katy, kalanchoe, calandiva), Bryophyllum daigremontianum (mother of thousands, devil's backbone3), K. beharensis (feltbush) These do contain toxins, and in their native South Africa, they have been responsible for killing grazing animals, but for all their popularity as houseplants, there are "no cases" (says Toxicity) of Kalanchoe spp. causing poisoning by ingestion. Allergic reactions are known, but don't appear to be severe. Toxicity recommends that Kalanchoe spp. "be considered of slight or no toxicological significance." So I do.
Neoregelia cvv. Bromeliads are safe under most circumstances and to most species; however, many Neoregelia spp. have spines on the edges of the leaves, like Cryptanthus spp., which could in theory cause injury if swallowed.
Pelargonium x hortorum (geranium) Some people are sensitive to a few specific compounds in geranium essential oil, and occasionally people develop skin irritation or an actual allergy. They don't appear to be otherwise toxic, though, and should be considered basically safe plants around children and pets.
Sedum morganianum (burro's tail), S.rubrotinctum (jellybean plant), other Sedum spp. (stonecrop) Not a lot of information about these, but what there is suggests that they irritate some people's skin. Reports of toxic reactions are very rare, and usually there are no symptoms. Likely okay around children and pets, including reptiles and amphibians.
Sempervivum spp. (hen and chicks, houseleek, stonecrop) As for Sedum spp., q.v.
Solenostemon scutellarioides (coleus, flame nettle) Cause allergic reactions in some people, and occasional non-allergic skin irritation. The later is more common in people who handle them a lot occupationally, though both reactions are rare. It appears to be safe if ingested.
Tradescantia pallida (purple heart, purple queen) A small percentage of people will develop skin irritation from handling them but this is of minimal consequence. Tradescantia spp. are one of the most commonly called-about plants for poison control centers, and are generally regarded as nontoxic for all species.
Tradescantia spathacea (Moses in the cradle, oyster plant) As for Tradescantia pallida, q.v.
Tradescantia zebrina (wandering Jew) As for Tradescantia pallida, q.v.
Yucca guatemalensis (spineless yucca) Neither Handbook nor Toxicity mentions Yucca guatemalensis. I did see a mention somewhere that ingestion causes vomiting and diarrhea in cats and dogs, but cat-and-dog digestive systems are obviously on a vomiting-and-diarrhea hair trigger anyway; I haven't seen anything about any other animal being poisoned by Y. guatemalensis. Flowers are incredibly unlikely indoors, but if some should form, they are said to be edible. The leaf tips, though spineless, do pose a slight mechanical danger, as do the serrated edges of the leaves: Lynn P. Griffith, Jr., author of the tropical plants growers' guide I like so much (see the sidebar), claims to have poked out an eardrum by bumping into the tip of a Yucca leaf.
Photo credits: All are my own.
1 Do we still hate her? She hasn't gone and done anything noble or selfless that I need to know about, has she?
2 From Toxicity of Houseplants again: "Three children, ages 3, 5, and 7 were disciplined by their parents by placing a split jalapeno pepper in their mouths and setting a timer for 15 to 20 min. If the pepper was spit out, the child vomited [!], or swallowed the pepper, another pepper was placed, and another 20 min was started. The children experienced burning of the mouth, throat, and stomach, and burning of the anus when passing stool. The children cried at night from residual pain. [alarmed look] Vomiting and diarrhea were also seen as a result of the treatment. School authorities discovered the abuse, authorities were notified, and the treatments discontinued." [Hopefully because the parents had been torn to pieces by an angry mob, arrested, jailed, and torn to pieces again by angry prisoners, but the account stops there so I don't know. The ability of human beings to invent new ways of being horrible to one another should stop surprising me at some point, you'd think, but apparently not yet.] (Toxicity of Houseplants references Tominack, R. L. and Spyker, D. A., Capsicum and capsaicin -- a review: case report of the use of hot peppers in child abuse, Clin. Toxicol., 25, 591, 1987.)
3 (Included here because B. daigremontianum was at one time included in the Kalanchoe genus under the name Kalanchoe daigremontiana.) Also, it annoys me to an unreasonable degree that "devil's backbone" is apparently an acceptable common name for Bryophyllum daigremontianum, despite it having no backboney characteristics whatsoever, as far as I'm aware. Though it does have some devilish tendencies, I admit. Pedilanthus tithymaloides deserves the name a lot more, and is a better plant.
Classic post, Mr. S! Your comments about dogs and cats are right on target. As for the abusive parents, surely a fit sentence would have been for them to have the world's hottest pepper, 'Bhut Jalokia', rubbed raw into all exposed membranes, with the treatment repeated each time the screams started to subside? I guess Hell was invented for people like this, so the rest of us could sleep at night. (Whatever's become of Paris Hilton, anyway?!)
There was (I hope it's past tense) a South American native culture where mothers punished their wayward daughters by rubbing the relevant parts with capsicum juices. Hurts just to write it.
I was shocked but not surprised to read about child abuse by capsicum. It just seem to be a more extreme version of "hot saucing," a type of punishment advocated in certain evangelical circles.
YOW! I hope the CIA doesn't find out about these uses for Capsicum. Thank you for the comments about the ASPCA. I think their food warnings are excessive like many nazi veterinarians.
Great series, Mr. S. I'll add my voice to the publication chorus -- perhaps as a PDF file? Then we could all print it and claim it as ours. (Wait, did I just type that out loud?) Anyhoo, keep up the good work and thanks for doing all the research the rest of us were too lazy to do ourselves. ;-)
Hm, soap, or hot peppers? I'm not going to get into the parenting debate, I'd write a thesis.
But there are benefits to the use of capsaisin--when I was 16, I went to NIH to get my wisdom teeth removed as part of a pain medication study. The active ingredient in the pain medication? Capsaisin. (Although I might have had the placebo, it was a double-blind study...)
Odd that something that causes so much pain can also relieve it, eh?
I found another source for KALANCHOE showing the plant to be medicinal rather than posionous.
I live in istanbul.. I was on a business trip in Libya Tripoli. I took a small kalanchoe out of soil which was about 10cm long. I applied mist in hotel room to keep it from dying. Anyhow.. planted in my balcony in Istanbul. The Kalanchoe is now 2m tall in less than 1.5 years, which shocks all my friends who are into plant and even prof. at the university.
The ladt that works in my house ( ukranian) she takes the small seedlings on the edge of leaves and keeps eating them saying they are the best medicine. She did not die for the last year.. so I decided to research and came across the web site above in addition to many sites claiming for posionous effect..
Just wanted to share it with you all.. any thoughts?
Stopping by VERY belatedly, but I couldn't resist adding a note here - I can't speak for all Chrysanthemum species, but Chrysanthemum coronarium is not only nontoxic, it's actually cultivated as a vegetable, with the flowers often used as an edible sushi garnish in Japan and the leaves stir-fried with sesame oil. You can probably find it at a local Asian supermarket.
(This is not to say I would recommend tasting other Chrysanthemum species, but at least one of them is harmless and tasty!)
Point taken, though for obvious reasons I'm assuming that the plants are of the species that would ordinarily be commonly sold in garden centers, supermarkets, etc. And few people who are looking for this information are going to have the ability to determine what species they have. It's safer to assume that they're all going to be unpleasant, than that they're all going to be delicious.
I got stuck in the abdomen by a Bougainvillea thorn while trimming one and it resulted in a horrendous rash that started as an itchy red area that swelled to half an inch thick, dark red, and expanded over weeks to cover a foot wide strip that encircled my waist. It took a couple months to totally go away.
Enjoying your site immensely already. Great reference material. It would be even better if you had photos for every plant you highlight. I love your light hearted approach too. On the more serious side, as regards the evil uses of capsicum, their is a terrible scene in the movie "Traffic" where a drug lord tortures a captured "competitor" by "blowing cayenne pepper powder" into the guy's nostrils. Try to imagine the pain of that. Turning to more positive things, I must let you know about the "only remedy" I know of if you have gotten oils from hot peppers on some external place on your body, especially eyes. BATH THE AREA IN MILK! It will absorb and neutralize the hot stuff. Believe me it works! I found out the hard way when, after cutting up some jalpenos and then taking a bath. Guess I touched myself "down there" and instantly I realized my folly, what to do.( btw, soap is NOT the answer. Think FAST! Dripping wet I ran to tbe kitchen, grabbed the milk,and back to the tub! Dousing my "nether region" in milk, the burning soon subsided. You may be grateful to me one day.
So remember never to pick or handle hot peppers without wearing latex or nitrite gloves. NEVER rub your eyes or "nether regions" after handling peppers. When eating hot food order milk��or a shake just in case. And remember, the seeds and membranes contain the capsicum, so if you like jalapenos in your food cut out and the seeds, and you'll get flavor with punishment. And always make sure you don't run out of milk. Btw, I have fallen love with growing hot peppers! Love plants.Pero estan muy peligroso�� ��h, and one last thing if crushing dried chilies were a paper medical mask and fit it tightly. No need to end up like that poor bugger in the movie?��������
Post a Comment