Well, the price depends on the size of the plant. If this is a good-sized plant, $34 could be justified. But everything else is clearly wrong.
'Lime Edge' looks like it might be pretty. But what I am looking for, and can never find, is a good, deep green, unscarred, healthy-looking, plain old 'Janet Craig'. I know they exist; I saw one, once.
Agree with Karen on the size of the plant - have seen massive Dracaenas sell for $220 (4 cane, at least 6' tall, 5 gallon/maybe 14" pot). That said you should be able to find a decent sized 10" plant for as little as $20 which is the most I would pay.
Otherwise all of the above?
Looks like a nice cultivar though, and fairly healthy (from the picture).
Most American limes are medium to dark green on the outside, though not as dark as the leaves of this plant. I think the color name "lime green" is a reference to the pulp, although that really isn't that yellow-green color, either.
When I first saw this, I took "Lime Edge Jenny Craig" to be all one cultivar name, or else I would have included "has two cultivar names" as one of the options. I've seen 'Art' called something along those lines on-line before, actually. Don't remember where, but it's sort of logical.
Andrew:
I've never seen a $220 Dracaena, but I've seen $120 ones where I used to work. This one might or might not have been worth $34: all this place's plants were packed so tightly together that it was hard to get a sense of how big most of them were without picking them up.
Pat:
Karen715 beat me to it, but just to support her point: I usually understand "lime green" to be a yellowish-green, not having anything to do with the color of actual limes. Greener than chartreuse, but only just. I don't know how this got started.
Plant needs bright light. There is a Dracena variety named 'Janet Craig Lemon-Lime', but I thought it had interior stripes, not light green leaf margins.
This plant is a much better outdoor planting than house plant - they tend to be leggy when they lack proper light conditions.
Agreed with another poster - would never pay more than 15-20 bucks for a large plant.
Have questions about PATSP? See the Infrequently Asked Questions post, or ask directly by e-mail. To e-mail, remove the two "d"s from the below address:
mrsubdjunctive@doutlook.com
Please note: I am a person, not a houseplant-care-advice vending machine. If you've asked a plant-care question and I responded, that took time and effort that I could have spent on something else, and it's nice if you acknowledge that with a "thank you."
Also: no, I will not help you draw attention to your Kickstarter. No, I do not need the services of a blog-ads optimizer. No, I'm not interested in promoting/reviewing/giving away your products. Fuck, no, I will not write for free for your blog. I know these things are important to you, and you feel that your case is so special that I would obviously make an exception to the rule if you asked me because of how special your thing is, but I assure you: it is not special, and I will not make an exception. (This means you, Mother Earth Living.)
As of 20 June 2021, comments may not be approved for several days, because Google / Blogger has made it less convenient for me to check them.
Lynn P. Griffith, Jr. Tropical Foliage Plants: a Grower's Guide (Amazon • B&N) Lynn P. Griffith, Jr. Tropical Foliage Plants: a Grower's Guide, 2nd Ed. (Amazon • B&N • Powell's)
Mr_Subjunctive used to work at a family-owned greenhouse / garden center in Iowa City, IA. As of 16 December 2021, he has 1234 houseplants, which is too damn many. Most are Schlumbergeras.
Photos on this blog attributed to mr_subjunctive are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License. All other photos retain the licensing preferences of their owners and require permission for reuse. Contact mr_subjunctive for help in locating the sources for other photos.
Text on this blog: all rights reserved. Text may not be duplicated by any means without permission of its author, who is actually pretty easygoing under most circumstances and will probably say okey-dokey if you ask to reproduce something (but you still have to ask, and credit mr_subjunctive as the author of the excerpted part).
11 comments:
Jenny Craig is the formerly-fat sister of Janet. She needs low light in order not to be able to find her way to the cookie jar.
Plant has two cultivar names. o.0
Not necessarily mutually incompatible, but... eh?
Well, the price depends on the size of the plant. If this is a good-sized plant, $34 could be justified. But everything else is clearly wrong.
'Lime Edge' looks like it might be pretty. But what I am looking for, and can never find, is a good, deep green, unscarred, healthy-looking, plain old 'Janet Craig'. I know they exist; I saw one, once.
Agree with Karen on the size of the plant - have seen massive Dracaenas sell for $220 (4 cane, at least 6' tall, 5 gallon/maybe 14" pot). That said you should be able to find a decent sized 10" plant for as little as $20 which is the most I would pay.
Otherwise all of the above?
Looks like a nice cultivar though, and fairly healthy (from the picture).
Definitely all of the above!
You are one funny cookie, mr_s! Jenny Craig, hahaha!
That's hilarious!
What colour are American limes? They are usually deep green when we get them in the UK. So this would be "Lime Middle"
Most American limes are medium to dark green on the outside, though not as dark as the leaves of this plant. I think the color name "lime green" is a reference to the pulp, although that really isn't that yellow-green color, either.
"Chartreuse Edge" probably isn't catchy enough.
Sixwing / Karen715:
When I first saw this, I took "Lime Edge Jenny Craig" to be all one cultivar name, or else I would have included "has two cultivar names" as one of the options. I've seen 'Art' called something along those lines on-line before, actually. Don't remember where, but it's sort of logical.
Andrew:
I've never seen a $220 Dracaena, but I've seen $120 ones where I used to work. This one might or might not have been worth $34: all this place's plants were packed so tightly together that it was hard to get a sense of how big most of them were without picking them up.
Pat:
Karen715 beat me to it, but just to support her point: I usually understand "lime green" to be a yellowish-green, not having anything to do with the color of actual limes. Greener than chartreuse, but only just. I don't know how this got started.
Plant needs bright light. There is a Dracena variety named 'Janet Craig Lemon-Lime', but I thought it had interior stripes, not light green leaf margins.
This plant is a much better outdoor planting than house plant - they tend to be leggy when they lack proper light conditions.
Agreed with another poster - would never pay more than 15-20 bucks for a large plant.
Post a Comment